DogCast Radio
Home Episodes Articles Blog Breed profiles Book reviews Photos Contact

So are you an owner or a guardian? (and does it really matter?)

I've been sent this email from a campaign that wants us to refer to ourselves as "guardians" rather than "owners". Now I'm not entirely in agreement with this campaign but I thought I'd post this to see what other people's reactions were. I know that in the US the word guardian, as opposed to owner, has gained popularity, but this is the first big push for such a move in the UK. My attitude is that I don't actually care what people call themselves as long as they meet their dog's needs and give them a good life. I don't think the language really is the key - you may talk the talk, but what really matters is walking the walk.

Another area this has cropped up in is that the word "crate" or "cage" can put people off using that piece of highly useful and beneficial equipment, and that we should instead refer to it as an indoor kennel or a puppy playpen. Again I really don't mind what you call it - the crux of the matter is that people understand that dogs actually like crates if they are introduced to them properly and that crates can help toilet train your dog, ensure they get the rest they need, keep them out of all sorts of mischief and danger - and from personal experience they can sometimes save your sanity!

Dogs don't understand language. Yes they can pick up a few words that relate to behaviours or objects, some of them can pick up a large number of those words, but they won't care whether you call a crate a luxury residing place, or refer to yourself as an owner or a guardian. They will however be hugely effected by the quality of the relationship you develop with them. I strive to have a strong, loving bond with our dogs, and I consider their welfare in every activity we undertake - but I call myself their owner. They are "mine" in the same way that my husband, daughter and mother are "mine"; and in that same spirit of mutual love and understanding, I am absolutely theirs.

Here's the press release from the Guardian Campaign, and I'd love to know what you think about it:

Writer launches campaign that challenges perceptions of animal “ownership” 

Change one word and change a life. Stop being an “owner” and start being a “guardian”. That’s the simple message from the Guardian Campaign. 

We own cars, computers and mobile phones. But we don’t own our partners or children because the concept of owning another living thing seems archaic. So why then do we still refer to ourselves as “owners” when it comes to our pets and animal companions? 

You don’t have to go back far in the history of humanity to a time when women, children and others were seen, in legal terms, as merely property. Finally, it seems society is ready to acknowledge that animals, too, are worth something more than their price tag.

In the UK the pet industry is worth an estimated £2 billion. We have more pet food manufacturers than ever; more pet insurance companies and more pet retailers, so clearly our animals mean lot to us. Which is why when we call ourselves their owners we devalue our relationship with them; it relegates them to mere items of property, commodities to buy, sell, misuse or destroy as we wish. 

To many people, pets are considered part of the family. Companions that make us feel less alone in an age where ironically, technology has made us increasingly isolated. They fulfil huge emotional needs and when they are gone, we grieve for them. 

The campaign is not tied to any company or organisation but has been launched by an individual; freelance writer Linda Goodman: 

“As a writer for the last 28 years, I understand the power of words. They can shift millions of pounds worth of goods. They can educate and enlighten. They can also denigrate and demoralise. In this instance we are talking about changing our use of one little word; owner. When I think of the word “owner”, I think of my car, or my computer. When I think of my pets I think “friends”, “companions”. They are not mine to own, but they are my responsibility to take care of. It’s a subtle change of language but it elevates the relationship we have with our animal companions to a level of care and respect that I believe is long overdue in the UK.”

The Guardian Campaign’s aim is to have people, companies, charities and organisations, make a conscious decision to use the word guardian instead of owner. It’s a simple change of mindset that Goodman believes can make a huge difference.

“Having worked behind the scenes for many animal charities and organisations throughout my life, it can sometimes feel like swimming against the tide. Our rescue centres are overflowing with unwanted, abandoned and neglected animals. Yet there is still indiscriminate puppy breeding for example, and those who shy away from spaying and neutering. And there are some who take on pets without fully understanding the commitment it involves. It is my greatest wish that by using the word guardian, not owner, we will start to see this situation improve." 

It’s a change that Goodman is calling for with the aim of helping the work of all welfare organisations, animal shelters and charities across the UK. Although the term does not change any legal standing, guardian denotes the responsibility people have for the care, welfare, treatment and quality of life of an animal in their charge.

"I also hope that vets will embrace this thought process and endorse the educational properties of the campaign towards responsible pet ownership. Perhaps once we change our use of language with our animal companions, this new level of respect will be extended to our wildlife – something we are all guardians of. And maybe, in time, we may learn to have a greater respect for ourselves and each other.”

It’s a change of language that millions around the world, including many celebrities, charities and welfare organisations have taken to heart. 

Refreshingly, it doesn’t require money and there’s nothing you need to join. It’s simply a campaign to educate and raise awareness, and of course a request to think about the way we use words and the impact we can have with them. 

For more information about the campaign and its supporters, please visit 

For more information about this press release please email 

You can follow the campaign's tweets @GuardianCamp



241 - Andy Hale and National Happy Dog Day

In celebration of National Happy Dog Day on 9th September, certified behaviourist Andy Hale advocates moving past the "how" of dog training, and focusing on the "why". Andy's priority is the dog's emotional experience, and he and Julie discuss how we can allow our dogs to be happy. Join in the discussion online with the hashtag #HappyDogDay.

189 - The Dog Healers and War Dogs Remembered

In this episode you can hear Mark Winik talk about his debut novel, The Dog Healers, and listen to Julia Robertson explain why she founded the charity War Dogs remembered. Plus there's the DogCast Radio News, and what Mischief the German Spitz puppy has been up to.

188 - Service Dogs UK and Roxie the Doxie Finds Her Forever Home

In this episode you can hear about Service Dogs UK, a fantastic charity which trains assistance dogs to support veterans of any service - military personnel, police, firefighters, paramedics and the coastguard - who develop Post Traumatic Stress Disorder due to their job. Also, listen to Dr Jody A Dean, a clinical psychologist talk about how her book, Roxie the Doxie finds her Forever Home, is helping children understand and talk about adoption and other family issues. Plus the DogCast Radio News and some thoughts on the alpha dog myth.

187 - Muffins Halo and Chorley Fun Dog Show

In this episode you can hear about Muffin's Halo for Blind Dogs, and what motivates people to enter their dog in a fun dog show. In the DogCast Radio News, listen to stories about the latest dog related research. Plus there's a new member of the DogCast Radio team!

186 - Maxwell Muir on wolves

In this episode you can hear trainer, behaviourist, writer, broadcaster and wolf expert Maxwell Muir talk about what wolves mean to him personally, their plight in a modern world, and his hopes for their future. Plus we have the DogCast Radio News.